When building or managing an enterprise network, the terms “switch” and “router” are fundamental. Though they often work in tandem to keep your business connected, they play very different roles in your IT infrastructure.
A network switch creates a network by connecting devices like computers, printers, and servers within a single local area network (LAN). A router, on the other hand, connects different networks together—most commonly, connecting your company's LAN to the internet.
Understanding this distinction is critical for designing a cost-effective and high-performing network. This guide breaks down the specific functions of each device, helping you make the right procurement decisions for your business.
What is a Network Switch?
A network switch acts as a central connection point for devices within a single local area network (LAN). It intelligently manages data flow, ensuring that information gets from one device to another efficiently. Operating at the data link layer (Layer 2) of the OSI model, a switch uses MAC addresses to forward data packets directly to the intended recipient device. This prevents unnecessary traffic from flooding the network, which improves overall speed and performance.
Essentially, a switch creates a series of instant, private connections between devices as needed. Its primary functions include:
- Connecting multiple devices such as computers, printers, and servers on a single LAN.
- Learning the unique MAC address of each connected device to build a forwarding table.
- Directing network traffic only to the specific port connected to the destination device.
- Reducing data collisions and network congestion to maintain high performance.
What is a Router?
A router operates at the network layer (Layer 3) of the OSI model, connecting your internal network to other networks, most notably the internet. It uses IP addresses to direct data packets to their correct destination outside of your local area network (LAN). Think of it as the traffic controller that manages the flow of information between your business and the outside world, ensuring data finds the most efficient path.
A router's core responsibilities include:
- Connecting two or more different networks, such as a LAN and a Wide Area Network (WAN).
- Forwarding data packets between these networks based on their destination IP address.
- Assigning local IP addresses to devices on the network using DHCP (Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol).
- Providing security through features like Network Address Translation (NAT) and firewalls to protect the internal network.
Key Differences Between Switches and Routers
While both are essential for network connectivity, their core functions and operational methods are fundamentally different. Here’s a closer look at what sets them apart.
Network Scope
The most fundamental difference lies in the scope of their operation. A switch is designed to operate within a single local area network (LAN), creating a network by connecting your internal devices.
A router, however, is built to connect different networks together. Its primary purpose is to manage traffic between your LAN and an external network, like the internet.
Data Forwarding Method
Switches and routers also handle data differently. A switch uses hardware-based MAC addresses to forward data frames to a specific device on the local network.
Conversely, a router uses software-configured IP addresses to direct data packets between networks. It analyzes IP addresses to determine the best path for data to travel from one network to another.
Address Tables
This difference in data handling extends to how they track devices. A switch maintains a simple MAC address table that maps each device's unique hardware address to a physical port.
A router uses a more sophisticated routing table. This table doesn't just track individual devices but stores information about network paths, allowing it to make intelligent decisions about where to send data.
When to Use a Switch in Your Network
A network switch is the right choice whenever you need to expand or manage device connectivity within a single location. If your goal is to connect multiple devices together to share resources locally, a switch is the essential tool for the job. Consider using a switch in the following scenarios:
- Expanding Network Capacity: When you run out of Ethernet ports on your existing router and need to connect more wired devices like computers, printers, or VoIP phones in an office.
- Improving LAN Performance: If your local network is slow due to a high volume of internal traffic, a switch can help by isolating traffic and sending data only to its intended device, reducing congestion.
- Connecting High-Bandwidth Devices: For linking servers, network-attached storage (NAS), or other devices that require fast, stable connections for large data transfers within your network.
- Segmenting Your Network: To create separate network segments for different departments (e.g., Finance, Engineering) without isolating them from each other completely, improving organization and internal security.
When to Use a Router in Your Network
A router is necessary whenever your network needs to communicate with the outside world or when you need to manage traffic between different networks. It’s the gateway for your internal devices. You should use a router in these key situations:
- Connecting to the Internet: This is the most common use case. A router is required to connect all the devices on your local area network (LAN) to your Internet Service Provider (ISP).
- Linking Multiple Office Locations: To connect the networks of different physical sites and create a cohesive Wide Area Network (WAN), routers are essential for directing traffic between locations.
- Managing Network Security: Routers act as the first line of defense, using firewalls and Network Address Translation (NAT) to protect your internal network from unauthorized external access.
- Providing Wireless Access: Most business routers include wireless capabilities, allowing you to create a Wi-Fi network for employees and guests to connect their devices without physical cables.
How to Choose Between a Switch and a Router
Choosing the right device doesn't have to be complicated. Your decision should be guided by your network's specific purpose and existing setup.
1. Define Your Primary Goal
Start by identifying the core task you need to accomplish. If your objective is simply to connect more devices within a single local network—like adding more computers or printers in one office—a switch is the correct tool.
If your goal involves connecting your entire office to the internet or linking separate networks together, you need a router.
2. Assess Your Existing Infrastructure
Take stock of what you already have. Most businesses receive a router from their Internet Service Provider (ISP) that provides basic connectivity and Wi-Fi.
If you have a router but have run out of physical ports, you don't need another router. Instead, you can connect a switch to an existing router port to easily and affordably expand your device capacity.
3. Consider Advanced Internal Routing
For more complex internal networks, you might encounter devices called Layer 3 switches. These are hybrid devices that operate primarily as switches but can also handle some basic routing tasks, like managing traffic between different internal network segments (VLANs).
While a router is still necessary for connecting to the internet, a Layer 3 switch can be a powerful tool for optimizing traffic flow within a large, segmented LAN.
Making the Right Choice for Your Enterprise
Ultimately, choosing between a switch and a router comes down to a simple question: are you connecting devices locally or connecting your network to the outside world? Both are fundamental to a well-functioning enterprise network, but they solve different problems.
- Use a switch to expand your network within a single location. It’s the right tool for connecting more computers, printers, and servers to your local area network (LAN).
- Use a router to connect different networks together. It’s essential for providing internet access to your LAN or linking multiple office sites across a wide area network (WAN).
In most business environments, you won’t choose one over the other—you’ll use them together. A switch adds more ports for your devices, while a router provides the critical connection to the internet and other locations.
Need Help Managing Your Network? Lightyear Can Help
Choosing the right hardware is just the first step. Managing the telecom services that connect your switches and routers—like internet and WAN—is where the real complexity begins.
By automating network service procurement, inventory management, and bill consolidation, Lightyear takes the pain out of telecom infrastructure management. The hundreds of enterprises who trust Lightyear achieve 70%+ time savings and 20%+ cost savings on their network services.
Schedule a demo or get started with our questionnaire today.
Frequently Asked Questions about Switch vs Router
Can a router also function as a switch?
Yes, most routers include a few built-in switch ports for connecting wired devices. However, for a business network with many devices, a dedicated switch is needed to handle the volume of local traffic efficiently and expand port capacity beyond what the router offers.
How does a modem fit in with a switch and a router?
A modem connects to your internet service provider's line and translates the signal. The router then plugs into the modem to create your network and manage internet traffic. A switch connects to the router to expand the number of devices that can join the local network.
Can I connect a switch to another switch?
Yes, this is a standard practice called "daisy-chaining" or "uplinking." It's a simple and effective way to add more ports to your local network. Just connect a cable from a port on the first switch to a port on the second one.
